Who Builds Your Addition? Subs, Crews and Oversight — BVM Homes

Who Actually Builds Your Toronto Addition, and Who Checks Their Work

TLDR: On almost every Toronto addition, most of the work is done by subcontractors, whoever you hire. That is normal and it is not the risk. The risk is a builder who hands the job to subs and stops watching. Ask any builder three things: who is on site every day and what is their job, who checks each trade's work before the next trade covers it, and what happens to a trade's payment when the work is wrong. At BVM, the quality of every build is also monitored by a Meagher, the family that started the company in 1997 and still owns it.

The question behind "can I trust you?"

On our discovery calls this fall, the question we heard most after "what will it cost?" was some version of this one: "Does your company do the work itself or sub it out? And who's watching them?"

It usually comes with a story. One homeowner told us their last builder handed the whole job to a single subcontractor. The roofline went up higher than the drawings without anyone asking them. The foundation was poured a foot off. Flooring was rushed in to hit a payment milestone. Their summary was the most honest thing we heard all season: "You lose trust after that first issue."

Nothing in that story is about whether subcontractors were used. Every part of it is about nobody checking.

What most homeowners get wrong

The common belief is that a good builder does the work with its own people and a bad builder subs it out. So homeowners ask "do you use subs?" and feel better when the answer is no.

Here is how a real addition gets built. Excavation, foundations, steel, framing, roofing, plumbing, HVAC, electrical, insulation, drywall and finishes are separate licensed trades with their own equipment and their own inspections. Very few builders keep all of them on payroll. At BVM, most of each job from demolition to finishes is done by trades we hire. What we keep in-house is the oversight: site supervisors and an internal team who monitor and quality-control our sites every day, and a Meagher checking the quality of every build.

So "do you use subs?" is the wrong question. It gets a yes from almost everyone, and the people who say no deserve the most follow-up.

The better question is how the builder runs the subs. And the clearest warning sign we know of is a contractor who will not work near home. Builders who run things off the books never want to work in their own backyard. We build almost entirely in Toronto's east end, from Birch Cliff to East York, which means our neighbours see every job we do.

Who is on site, and what their job is

Ask who is on site every day, and then ask what that person spends the day doing.

On our new projects, the site manager is off the tools. Their job is supervision, the schedule and quality control, looking one to two weeks ahead so the next trade arrives to a site that is ready for them. The project manager is the client's main contact and plans two or more weeks out. Small in-between tasks, like demolishing a stair or framing a wall, go to a trade rather than pulling the site manager away from watching the job.

Three things to listen for in a builder's answer:

  • Is the supervisor a person on payroll or another subcontractor? We do not hire subcontracted project managers. A sub supervising subs has no one above them on site.

  • How many jobs is that person spread across? We take on 6 to 9 projects a year. A site manager on our team spends most of their time on one main project and helps the others the rest of the week.

  • Does anyone whose name is on the company look at the work? At BVM, the quality of every build is monitored by a Meagher. The family that started the company in 1997 still owns it, and the people whose name is on the sign are the ones checking the work.

Who checks the work before it gets covered

A mistake in the framing or the rough-ins is a small fix while the walls are open. Once insulation and drywall go in, the same mistake means opening finished walls, and someone has to argue about who pays. So the question that matters most is when the work gets checked.

Here is the sequence we run between framing and drywall:

  1. Framing checked against the drawings by us first. We check the framing ourselves before we bring in the engineer for their site review, so the engineer's visit confirms the work instead of finding the problems.

  2. Mechanical layout walk with the trades. After framing, the plumber, HVAC and electrical trades walk the house together so their runs do not fight each other inside the same walls.

  3. Client walk the next day. You stand in each room and confirm switch, outlet and fixture locations while moving one is still a five-minute job.

  4. Final walk after the rough-ins, before insulation and drywall. Last look before anything is closed up.

Behind that sits a stage checklist of roughly 50 stages, from underpinning to blocking in the framing for things you will hang later, so details do not depend on someone remembering them. And our standing instruction to everyone on site is to add anything that looks off to the deficiency list, because it is better to get ahead of it before the client finds it.

This shows up at inspection. On a recent east-end addition, the City's building inspection passed in under two minutes, because the site was clean and organized and we had submitted the spray foam report a day early. Inspectors notice the same things you would.

What happens when a trade gets it wrong

This is where a builder's answer tells you the most, because it is about money.

Every trade on a BVM job quotes its full scope in writing and walks the site before demolition starts. If a trade later says an item was not in their price after walking the site with the full takeoffs, that miss is theirs to carry, not yours. Any extra work, of any size, needs a BVM purchase order before it starts, even if someone on site asks for it, and work done without one is not paid. Trades who leave a mess can be short-paid under their purchase order conditions.

Have we ever pulled a trade off a job partway through? Yes. It is rare, but we have been building since 1997, and we would be lying if we said it never happened. What changed over those years is who we hire. Our standards for subcontractors have gotten tighter and tighter, to the point where our core group stands behind its work. They know how we work and they know what is expected of them. In the last few years, we have not had to pull a trade off a job.

That chain matters to you for a simple reason. On a fixed-price job, a trade's mistake is our cost, not a change order on your bill. That is the incentive working the right way: we are motivated to lock in pricing with our trades and hold them to it, because if we do not, that is on us.

Ask your builder how they handle a trade who misses scope or does poor work. If the answer is vague, assume the cost lands with you.

How you see it without being on site

You should not have to visit every day to know what is happening, and the trades should not be taking instructions from three different people.

Our crews post photos and a daily log to the job record every day. Those logs come to our team first, for review, before they go to you, which makes the crews report more thoroughly, not less. Changes go through one channel. When you ask for something to change, we explain why to the crew before they do the work, so nobody on site is guessing at what you wanted. One person on our team stays your consistent contact for the whole job, with a check-in every two weeks.

Key Takeaways

  • Almost every Toronto addition is mostly built by subcontractors. "Do you use subs?" is the wrong question.

  • Ask who is on site daily, whether they are on the builder's payroll, and how many jobs they are covering. Then ask whether the owners ever look at the work themselves.

  • The work that matters most gets checked between framing and drywall. Ask for the builder's walkthrough sequence for that stretch.

  • Ask what happens to a trade's payment when the work is wrong or scope is missed. On a fixed-price job, that should be the builder's problem.

  • A builder who will not work near home is the clearest warning sign we know of.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do general contractors in Toronto use subcontractors? Yes, nearly all of them, for most of the work on an addition. Excavation, framing, roofing, mechanical, electrical, insulation and drywall are separate trades. What separates builders is how they schedule, check and pay those trades, not whether they use them.

Who should be supervising my addition every day? A site manager employed by the builder whose job is supervision, scheduling and quality control rather than doing the work. Ask how many projects that person covers. A subcontractor supervising other subcontractors has nobody above them on site.

When should I visit the site? At the walkthroughs that matter: after framing, to confirm switch, outlet and fixture locations, and before insulation and drywall go in. Your builder should invite you to both. Between those, daily photo logs should tell you what happened that day.

Thinking about an addition?

If you are comparing builders and want to see how our process works before anything is drawn, book a discovery call. It is free and takes 30 minutes, and we will tell you honestly if your project is a fit. For homeowners ready to plan, our Design & Feasibility Sprint settles what your lot allows, what the house can take and what it will cost, before you commit to drawings.

Related Reading

About the author. Ryan Meagher is Pre-Construction Manager at BVM Homes, the Toronto home addition and renovation company his family started in 1997. He has been quoted on renovation costs and planning by Fortune, CBC News and the Toronto Star. More about Ryan.